4.9 from 69 Google reviews Read reviews Blog
Home / Blog / Waterproofing

Plumbing hints and tips

Leaking shower: grout, silicone or failed waterproofing?

A leaking shower isn't always obvious from the start. You might notice a damp patch on the ceiling below, soft skirting boards in the next room, or tiles that sound hollow when you tap them. By the time water shows up somewhere else, the damage behind your tiles has often been happening for months.

The question most people ask is whether they need to regrout, replace the silicone, or pull the whole shower apart and start again. The answer depends on where the water is actually escaping, and that's not always where you think.

Grout and silicone are not waterproofing

Grout between tiles is porous. It slows water down, but it doesn't stop it. Silicone around the edges of your shower tray or along the hob is a seal, but it's not a barrier against water sitting on the surface for any length of time.

The real waterproofing sits underneath the tiles. It's a membrane applied to the substrate before any tiling begins. If that membrane wasn't installed properly, or if it's been punctured or degraded over time, water will find its way through the grout, past the silicone, and into the wall or floor cavity.

Regrouting and replacing silicone can fix cosmetic wear and improve the look of your shower, but if the leak continues after that work is done, the membrane is the problem.

When grout or silicone is enough

If the grout has cracked in a few spots or the silicone bead around your shower screen has lifted, and there's no sign of water damage elsewhere, a repair might be all you need. Fresh grout and a clean silicone seal will tidy things up and buy you some time.

But if you've noticed soft or discoloured grout across a wide area, tiles that move slightly underfoot, or water stains spreading on the other side of the wall, you're looking at something deeper.

Silicone has a lifespan. It perishes, lifts and cracks, especially around hinge points and joins. Replacing it every few years is normal. What's not normal is water appearing in places it shouldn't be, even when the silicone looks intact.

Signs the waterproofing membrane has failed

The membrane can fail for a few reasons. Poor installation is the most common. If it wasn't lapped correctly at joins, taken high enough up the walls, or sealed properly around penetrations like mixer outlets and waste fittings, water will get through.

Over time, movement in the building, failed adhesive, or even a badly placed screw during a grab rail install can puncture the membrane. Once there's a hole, water follows.

You'll often see these signs:

  • Damp or peeling paint on the wall outside the shower
  • Ceiling stains in the room below
  • Musty smell that doesn't go away
  • Soft or spongy flooring near the shower
  • Tiles that lift or sound hollow
  • Mould that keeps coming back no matter how much you clean

If you're ticking more than one of those, the membrane is likely compromised.

What a proper repair looks like

A leaking shower caused by failed waterproofing means stripping the tiles, removing the old membrane, repairing or replacing the substrate if it's damaged, then installing a new membrane and retiling. It's not a quick fix, and it's not cheap, but it's the only permanent solution.

Trying to seal over the top with grout or silicone when the membrane has failed will not stop the leak. You'll keep patching, the water will keep moving, and the damage will keep spreading.

On Sydney's North Shore, we've opened up more than a few showers where the membrane was either missing entirely, not taken up the walls far enough, or torn during the tile install. It's frustrating for the homeowner, but once it's done properly, the problem is solved.

For advice on waterproofing and leak repairs across the Lower North Shore, take a look at our bathroom waterproofing service.

How we find the source

We start with a visual inspection. We'll check the grout, the silicone, the fall of the floor, and any obvious damage. If the cause isn't clear, we can run a flood test or use moisture detection tools to map where the water is travelling.

Sometimes the fault is obvious. Other times, water is tracking sideways through a wall cavity or along a joist before it appears somewhere completely unrelated to the shower itself.

Once we know what's leaking and why, we'll talk you through your options and give you upfront pricing, agreed before we start.

Common questions

Can I just regrout and see if the leak stops? You can, and if the leak is very minor and only happening at the surface, it might work for a while. But if the waterproofing membrane underneath has failed, regrouting won't fix it.

How long does a waterproofing membrane last? A properly installed membrane should last decades. Failures usually come from poor installation, building movement, or accidental damage rather than the membrane wearing out on its own.

Do I need to retile the whole shower? If the membrane needs replacing, yes. You can't access it without removing the tiles, and once they're off, they generally can't be reused. The good news is you'll have a watertight shower that won't cause any more damage.

If your shower's leaking and you're not sure whether it's a simple seal or something more serious, we'll help you work it out without the guesswork.

Call STS Plumbing on 9904 3074 or book a visit.

Need a local plumber?

Ring the office and we will tell you what it usually is, what it usually costs and when we can be there.